One of America’s most notorious jails could finally be shutting its doors.
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced his plan Friday to finally close Rikers Island, the city’s notorious jail complex, by the end of 2032. But the young mayor’s proposal is already facing opposition from at least one City Council member, who believes the city should fix Rikers instead of spending billions to replace it.
The announcement hits after years of delays and criticism over the violence, deaths, poor medical care and dangerous conditions inside the jail. New York City originally passed a law requiring Rikers to close by August 2027, but Mamdani’s proposal would push that deadline back more than five years.
What remains unclear is how building smaller jails will solve the same problems that have plagued Rikers Island for decades: drugs, violence and chronic staffing shortages
“It is time to finally close Rikers Island,” Mamdani said in a statement Friday. “For decades, New Yorkers have demanded a correctional system that is safe and humane.”

Under the mayor’s new plan, the city would build four smaller jails in Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens and the Bronx, with the first expected to open in Brooklyn in 2029. The remaining facilities would open by the end of 2032, allowing the city to gradually move incarcerated people and correctional staff off Rikers.
The administration also plans to invest $146 million next fiscal year in mental health treatment, substance abuse programs, job training, education, community services and assistance for crime victims. Another 236 specialized hospital beds would also be added for incarcerated people with serious mental illnesses or complex medical needs.
The plan also aims to reduce the city’s jail population to no more than 4,100 people by 2032, partly by addressing lengthy court delays and alternatives to lock-up. Some city-goers aren’t so sure that having less criminals in jail is a good thing.
Mamdani also argues that moving jails closer to courthouses, public transportation and neighborhoods will make it easier for detainees to see their families and attorneys while improving safety for correction officers.
Republican City Councilman Frank Morano of Staten Island isn’t buying it. Morano, who serves on the Council’s Committee on Criminal Justice, announced Friday that he will oppose legislation needed to extend the closure deadline. He argues that the city should instead build modern correctional facilities on Rikers Island, which it already owns.
“We have an entire island that the City already owns, geographically separated from residential neighborhoods, where we could build modern correctional facilities,” Morano said. “I have never understood how changing the ZIP code of a jail is supposed to fix the way it’s run.”
Morano also cited concerns about the cost of the project, pointing to estimates that construction of the borough-based jails has ballooned from $8 billion to $16 billion. He questioned whether the new facilities would have enough space, as they are designed to hold 4,500 people while the current jail population is around 6,600.
“The number of jail beds we build should be determined by our public safety needs,” Morano said. “Our public safety decisions should not be determined by the number of jail beds politicians have decided to build.”
Morano isn’t the only person questioning the original closure strategy. In a Nov. 17 guest essay for The New York Times, Elizabeth Glazer, who helped develop the plan while serving as criminal justice director under former Mayor Bill de Blasio, argued that the city should reconsider. She suggested renovating facilities on Rikers while continuing construction of the borough-based jails.
A source who works inside Rikers Island told Los Angeles Magazine that the city’s plan fails to address the violence, staffing shortages and security problems correction officers face daily. The source also questioned whether moving thousands of detainees into smaller jails near residential neighborhoods would make anyone safer. “The media loves to blame NYC Correction officers when inmates die, but maybe there would be fewer deaths if drugs weren’t being smuggled in by dirty officers, civilian workers, and visitors. Rikers is one of the most violent jails in America, with daily inmate-on-inmate slashings and constant assaults on staff—and that’s who civilian planners want to move into borough-based jails right next door to residential neighborhoods? Fitting over 6,500 detainees into 4,100 borough beds doesn’t even work mathematically. Stop rushing a dangerous plan: hire more officers, pay us what we’re worth, and build state-of-the-art, secure facilities on Rikers Island for everyone’s safety.”
Other city officials are backing Mamdani’s proposal, including City Council Speaker Julie Menin, who acknowledged that delays under previous administrations have made the original deadline unrealistic.
“Delays under previous administrations have made it clear that more time is needed to fulfill the commitment the City Council made to New Yorkers in 2019 when we legislated closing Rikers Island,” Menin said in the city’s official announcement. “With Rikers now under federal court-ordered oversight, we must bring this troubling chapter in our city’s history to an end once and for all.”
City Councilman Yusef Salaam, one of the five Black and Latino teenagers wrongfully convicted in the notorious 1989 Central Park jogger case, is also on board. Salaam, who spent nearly seven years in prison before his conviction was overturned, now represents Harlem on the City Council.
“Rikers Island has been a stain on our city for far too long, and I know that firsthand,” Salaam said. “I’m proud to stand with Mayor Mamdani as he lays out a real path to close it for good and build a justice system rooted in dignity, safety and second chances.”
New York Attorney General Tish James also endorsed the plan, pointing to concerns about sexual assault, violence, neglect and poor medical care at Rikers. She did not explain how the new jails are immune to the violence and sexual assaults that currently plague the jail.
The proposal is far from a done deal. The City Council must approve legislation changing the existing closure deadline, and Morano has already made clear he plans to vote against it.
The Rikers announcement comes just four days after Mamdani and NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch announced the disbanding of the department’s elite Strategic Response Group, a specialized unit responsible for counterterrorism operations and responding to major protests. The Nov. 16 decision fulfilled a campaign promise by Mamdani, who argued that peaceful protesters should not face the same police response as terrorist threats. Under the restructuring, counterterrorism duties will move to the NYPD’s Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau, while a new “civilian led” division will help manage demonstrations.
The post One of America’s Most Notorious Jails Could Finally Close appeared first on LAmag.