Ex-Horry County Police Officers’ attorneys say poor decisions weren’t crimes

Posted

Nov 20, 2026 · Myrtle Beach News https://x.com/myrtlebeachnews

For more than two years, Scott Spivey’s family has argued that the way the Horry County Police Department handled his death was as much a part of the story as the gunfire on Camp Swamp Road. This week, a state grand jury moved that argument into a criminal courtroom. Former Deputy Chief Brandon Strickland and former Sgt. Paul “Damon” Vescovi, both identified as Ex-Horry County Police Officers, now face charges tied to their conduct after the September 2023 shooting.

What stood out at Thursday’s bond hearing in Kershaw County was not a denial of what happened. It was a concession. Neither defense lawyer told the judge his client had acted well. Both argued, in effect, that acting badly is not the same as committing a crime. Strickland’s attorney summed up his client’s recorded remarks as perhaps “not probably the best idea” — but not criminal.

That gap between poor judgment and criminal intent is likely to define this case. For Horry County residents, it also raises a harder question: what does accountability look like when the people being judged were the ones trusted to investigate?

The case raises significant concerns about the actions of the Ex-Horry County Police Officers involved and the implications for law enforcement accountability in the community.

Ex-Horry County Police Officers: Accountability and Transparency

The charges and what prosecutors allege

Strickland is charged with misconduct in office, obstruction of justice and criminal conspiracy. Vescovi is charged with misconduct in office and obstruction of justice. The officer charges came one day after a Horry County grand jury indicted Weldon Boyd and Kenneth “Bradley” Williams on murder and firearm charges in Spivey’s death. Those indictments allege the two men acted together, either as accomplices or through mutual combat; both have maintained they acted in self-defense [Live 5 News, 2026].

The officer charges grew out of a State Grand Jury investigation that lasted months, led by 7th Circuit Solicitor Barry Barnette, whom then-Attorney General Alan Wilson appointed to review the case. Prosecutors allege both men used their badges to help Boyd after the shooting.

The allegations against each officer are different in kind.

Vescovi was the second officer to reach the scene. His own body camera recorded him holding up a handwritten note to Boyd and Williams that read “Act like a victim. Camera. The department fired him on April 30, 2025, during an internal affairs review.

Strickland’s case rests largely on recorded phone calls. According to reporting from the hearing, he was a close friend of Boyd, assured him in those calls that he was being looked after, and declined to come to the scene himself, citing their friendship. In another call, Strickland spoke approvingly of the lead investigator and said he had made contacts and sent that investigator to the scene. Barnette told the court Strickland never passed along information Boyd shared with him, and suggested the obstruction reached beyond the shooting itself to other possible crimes. In one recorded call, prosecutors said, Boyd worried that a police search of his phone would expose banking information and unreported cash.

Those are the state’s allegations. The defense tells a very different story about the same recordings.

The defense: admit the act, dispute the crime

Bert von Herrmann, representing Strickland, told the court the evidence shows his client trying to keep his distance from the case while supporting a friend in crisis. He disputed that Boyd ever reported other crimes to Strickland, and characterized the remarks on the calls as inappropriate bluster rather than criminal acts. He also noted Strickland’s two decades with the county and three years of military service, said he had cooperated with the solicitor, SLED and HCPD, and asked for a personal-recognizance bond.

Brad Richardson, representing Vescovi, made a parallel argument. His client spent 23 years with the department and was working an overtime shift that night, Richardson said, relying on 911 calls that described a dangerous driver. In that telling, Vescovi believed Boyd was the victim of road rage when he wrote the note, and his choice was poor but not illegal [Post and Courier, 2026]. Richardson rejected the idea of a coordinated cover-up, saying “there was no grand conspiracy, no hiding of the body camera”.

Attorneys for all four defendants also argued that heavy publicity has tainted the case [Associated Press, 2026]. The judge set bond at $10,000 for each former officer, and both were released from J. Reuben Long Detention Center that evening.

If that is the defense, the real fight ahead is about something no recording can show directly: what each man intended.

Analysis: why “bad idea” versus “crime” is the whole case

Horry County Police to Federal Court

The defense strategy here is a familiar one in cases against public officials. When the key evidence is on video or audio, there is little point arguing it didn’t happen. So the fight shifts to state of mind.

That matters because each charge, in its own way, depends on purpose. Broadly speaking, misconduct in office is about an official knowingly misusing the authority of the job, not just doing it poorly. Obstruction is about acting to impede justice. Conspiracy requires an agreement. A jury could conclude that Vescovi’s note was reckless, even indefensible, and still have to decide whether he wrote it to shape an investigation or because he misread a chaotic scene in the moment. That timing question — what he knew when he picked up the pen — is likely to be central.

Strickland’s case turns on how a jury reads the same set of facts. The defense says declining to go to the scene shows a friend stepping back. The prosecution’s account — that he reassured Boyd, sent a specific investigator, and kept what Boyd told him to himself — invites a jury to see the same choices as steering rather than stepping back. The solicitor’s reference to “other possible crimes” hints that the state may try to show a motive larger than friendship: protecting Boyd from broader exposure.

There is also something residents should not lose sight of. Even the officers’ own lawyers now concede that their clients’ conduct fell short. An acquittal on criminal charges would not answer the institutional questions this case has raised. HCPD’s own internal review found that seven dashcam videos connected to the shooting had been mishandled and mislabeled. A criminal trial tests whether two individuals broke the law. It does not test whether the department’s systems — for evidence, for supervision, for keeping friends of suspects away from their cases — worked.

How the case got here: a family did the digging

The road to Thursday’s hearing ran mostly through a civil courtroom, not a police station. After Spivey was killed on Sept. 9, 2023, the Attorney General’s Office declined to charge Boyd in April 2024, citing insufficient evidence. In August 2025, the office told SLED it believed the state’s stand-your-ground law applied. Two months later, Wilson asked Barnette to take a fresh look.

Meanwhile, Spivey’s sister, Jennifer Foley, used her wrongful-death lawsuit to obtain a large collection of recorded phone calls — including conversations between Boyd and the department’s second-highest-ranking official. The “act like a victim” note itself was first spotted in Vescovi’s body-camera footage by journalist Beth Braden, who passed it to the family’s attorney. In February 2026, a circuit judge denied Boyd’s request for stand-your-ground immunity in the civil case, and denied Williams’ in a written order that March. In September, a separate federal lawsuit accused county police of concealing evidence and coaching witnesses.

The uncomfortable lesson for Horry County is that much of the evidence now driving criminal charges surfaced because a grieving family had the resources and persistence to pursue it through civil discovery. In court Thursday, Foley asked, in essence, who the public is supposed to trust if not the police. That is a fair question for county leaders as well as for a jury.

What’s Next

Judge Heath Taylor, who oversees State Grand Jury cases, heard Thursday’s matter in Kershaw County only because he was sitting there that day; he indicated the trial would likely be held in Horry County. No trial date has been set, and attorneys said a trial could come in 2027. Lawyers for Boyd and Williams said they expect to file motions to keep certain evidence out before trial. The civil wrongful-death case has been paused for 180 days. HCPD said the men are former employees and declined to comment on pending proceedings.

The family’s attorney, Mark Tinsley, called the indictments “an important step toward accountability,” while reminding the public that an indictment is not a conviction. All four defendants are presumed innocent unless proven guilty.

Questions worth watching in the months ahead:

  • Whether pretrial publicity becomes the basis for a request to move the trial out of Horry County.
  • Whether more current or former officers are charged as the investigation continues.
  • Whether Horry County Council or HCPD adopt clear rules requiring officers to step away from cases involving friends or associates.
  • How the federal civil suit’s claims about evidence handling are answered in court.

The defense has framed this as a story of bad decisions. The trial will decide whether it was something more.

Further Reading

Ex-Horry County Police Officers: Post and Courier: ‘Not probably the best idea’: Ex-Horry County officers’ attorneys say poor decisions weren’t crimes

Ex-Horry County Police Officers: WBTW: 2 former Horry County police officers charged in Scott Spivey case

Ex-Horry County Police Officers: WMBF: Former Horry County deputy chief, sergeant charged in Scott Spivey investigation

Ex-Horry County Police Officers: Live 5 News: Boyd, Williams indicted on murder charges in Scott Spivey’s death

Ex-Horry County Police Officers: Associated Press via Daily Journal: 2 men cleared in South Carolina road rage shooting now face charges

Ex-Horry County Police Officers: WPDE: New federal suit claims evidence was concealed, witnesses coached in 2023 Spivey shooting

Ex-Horry County Police Officers: WBTW: ‘You were taken care of’: Spivey’s sister shares phone call made minutes after deadly 2023 shootout

Ex-Horry County Police Officers: WBTW: ‘It’s traumatizing’: Court filings shed new details on chaotic scene

News, Featured, Government